Especially when accompanied by a good chuckle or two. Caleb Hannan at the Scene’s Pith in the Wind blog makes our day:

C’mon liberals. Let’s give Phil Valentine a break. He spends upwards of 10 to 15 minutes every Friday afternoon texting his column 160 characters at a time to a harried Tennessean editor. The least you can do is stop drooling.

Oh sure, we know that in the wake of GM CEO Rick Wagoner’s forced dismissal you’re all “salivating to take over everything.” But let’s at least try to remain civil. All that mouth juice rolling off your chin makes the keys on Phil’s Blackberry sticky. And do you know how hard it is to T9 polysyllabic mainstays like “socialism” after that spittle dries out? No, you don’t.

So without further ado here’s Phil’s latest

Thanks, Caleb!

  • Share/Bookmark

I’m looking for a little “word up” from anyone on the right about this Voter Confidence Act kerfuffle.

Anyone? Anyone?

Slater? Gill? Valentine? DelGiorno? Bristol?

Aren’t free and fair elections something we can all agree on? Don’t you guys see the dangers inherent in electronic voting?

I can only assume that like us, you want to win elections fairly. Wouldn’t it be nice to all be working towards that goal together?

  • Share/Bookmark

Phil Valentine’s Column Watch: Two Down…

It looks like Mr. Bruce Barry might have started something with his Pith in the Wind post complaining about Phil Valentine’s Tennessean column (“What Does an Op-Ed Columnist Have to Do to Get Fired Around Here?”). The Wilson County Post, serving Lebanon, Watertown, and Mt. Juliet, has decided to “discontinue publishing” Phil Valentine’s column in their Gallatin and Hendersonville newspapers. CEO Sam Hatcher writes:

We have made a decision to discontinue publishing in our Gallatin and Hendersonville newspapers the column provided to us weekly by radio talk show host Phil Valentine.

His most recent column published Sunday in The Tennessean was so-to-speak the straw that broke the camel’s back.

His insensitive remarks about what “his” country or “his” federal government is doing for him is self promoting, egotistical and in our opinion not fit for print in today’s world of war and economic turmoil.

Specifically Mr. Valentine questions “what am I getting for my federal income tax?”

Perhaps he would want to ask the mother of a National Guardsman or regular army recruit killed on a battlefield in a far away land that question.

Or maybe he would want to review the actions of the U.S. Supreme Court, which his tax dollars fund, that ensure he can speak his antagonistic words freely.

His federal tax dollars, my federal tax dollars and your federal tax dollars provide for all Americans a quality of life unlike any other in the world today.

We are Republicans, Democrats, Independents, Christians, Jews and Hindu. We are black and white and red and other colors. Some of us gather in the evening without bread on our table while others of us eat bountifully. But we are all Americans.

Oh, there’s more. And it’s good.

Email Mr. Hatcher with words of support or better yet, subscribe to his fine newspaper.

Hat tip to Veronica Rexford, who writes the column “Veer Left” for the paper. (Link forthcoming…)

  • Share/Bookmark

Good thing I checked the local blogs before sitting down to quell my frustration and anger by writing about Phil Valentine’s latest pack of lies and obfuscations in Sunday’s Tennessean. Bruce Barry, writing for the Nashville Scene’s Pith in the Wind beat me to it. Thanks, Bruce, for saying exactly what I wanted to say with much more eloquence. I’m reprinting Bruce’s post in its entirety. And stealing the picture, too. With a slight modification.

I realize that calling out Phil Valentine for his rhetorical hallucinations is old hat, but he outdid himself in his latest Sunday assault on reality. Yesterday Phil used his Tennessean column to showcase his abject ignorance about constitutional law, rehashing a simplistic and misinformed argument that no legal basis for disentangling government and religion exists since the phrase “separation of church and state” doesn’t appear in the U.S. Constitution. Wrapping his rant around the latest religious misadventure in Wilson County Schools, Phil goes the extra mile by reinventing some recent history:

The American Civil Liberties Union sued the Wilson County schools a couple of years ago over the annual See You at the Pole event and the National Day of Prayer….A federal judge threw the case out. Even though they lost, it was apparently enough to spook school administrators.

“Threw the case out” is, to say the least, a creative reinterpretation of U.S. District Court Judge Robert L. Echols’ 59-page finding that:

The [plaintiffs] have proved by a preponderance of the evidence that they suffered a constitutional violation and they will suffer a continuing irreparable injury if they are not able to enroll their children in Lakeview because Lakeview is not complying with First Amendment religious freedoms…The Court will grant the [plaintiffs] limited permanent injunctive relief.

We all realize that facts are a fleeting and optional commodity in conservative talk radio, but isn’t it high time that The Tennessean stopping giving prime Sunday op-ed real estate to a lowbrow hack who just makes shit up? (Disclosure: I sit on the ACLU of Tennessee board.)

I would like to add, however, in response to Valentine’s’ assertion that you never hear of the ACLU “rushing to the aid of someone who’s had their religious rights violated unless that religion happens to be anything but Christianity,” that yes, the ACLU does that all the freakin’ time, jackass.

  • Share/Bookmark

Steve Gill’s Birthday Suit

One of the things most worrisome about last week’s English Only special election was the effect that anti-immigrant right-wing ideologue mouthpieces Steve Gill, Phil Valentine, and Michael “It’s Delivery Not” DelGiorno, would have on the outcome. Let’s face it, two hours a week of us presenting reasoned and well-rounded interviews and opinion opposing the referendum versus 11 hours a day of them presenting bratty fear-based lies, half-truths, and accusations had us a little worried.

Not anymore! Last week’s election showed that we should have more faith in our listeners, the power of the grass roots coalitions, well-reasoned debate, and civil dialogue.

It’s not just Eric Crafton’s English Only that was defeated on Thursday. The brand of name-calling alarmism practiced by the three mouthkateers (can Tom Negri, General Manager of Loews Vanderbilt Hotel, or Rev. Jim Lawson, civil rights icon, really be defined as “liberal-wackos”?) was also given the smackdown by facts, figures, and the intellectual optimism practiced by a wide coalition of business, community, and spiritual leaders.

At this point, Gill et. al. should be frightened. Although they would never admit it, they know their fearmongering has both limited appeal and a limited shelf-life. Which is why hanging on to it while the rest of the country strides ahead is bad for business. Those boys say that they are giving people what they want, but our show – which with only 2 hours a week on a non-commercial station and engaging, reasonable guests, helped to defeat a city-wide referendum – clearly shows that they are so not. These emperors have not a stitch on.

The arguments against the Fairness Doctrine or the viability of progressive talk radio are red herrings use to deflect what DelGiorno, et. al. are really afraid of – that in these times, the majority of people in Middle-Tennessee would rather do what we do – discuss how public policy, elections, and elected officials can best serve the people of Tennessee – rather than what they specialize in – fear-based and divisive bombast (cue tax! abortion! immigration! gun! discussions). And they have no earthly idea how to adapt.

  • Share/Bookmark

Mayor Karl Dean will join Governor Phil Bredesen at the Howard School Building on Monday morning, Jan. 12, at 8:00 am to early vote against Councilman Eric Crafton’s “English-only” charter amendment and Amendment No. 2, which would make it absurdly easy to bring these kinds of referendums to a public vote (twice a year!). Then, the next day, Andrea Conte (Mrs. Governor Bredesen), Anne Davis (Mrs. Mayor Dean) and Martha Cooper (Mrs. Congressman Cooper, who let’s us call her “Mrs. Coop!”*) will do the same at 12:30 p.m.

Today, African-American leaders, community organizers, and public officials including Rep. Brenda Gilmore, Councillady Erica Gilmore, and Councilman at large Jerry Maynard, held a press conference in front of the Howard School to encourage votes of “Against/Against.” The coalition standing with them included representatives from the Nashville branch of the NAACP; the Urban EpiCenter; the Urban League of Middle Tennessee; the Interdenominational Ministers Fellowship (IMF); the Tennessee Immigrant & Refugee Rights Coalition (TIRRC); the Nashville Movement; the Tennessee Alliance for Progress (TAP); Jobs with Justice (JwJ); and the National Organization for Women (NOW).

The remarks focused on the social, economic, spiritual and moral impact of the referendum as well as the myth that most African-Americans were for the referendum. Although no statistics were cited, Councilman Maynard did explain that a lingering resentment over a lack of coalition building in response to school rezoning, the operation of Metro General Hospital, and juvenile crime statistics could be responsible for fueling pro-English Only sentiment in the African-American community. Maynard’s answer to such resentment is to cite the potential negative impact of the English Only referendum on the city and offer the tried and true adage of “two wrongs don’t make a right.”

The Mayor, the Governor, respected community leaders of all kinds. The coalition against the referendum is impressive. The list on the NashvilleForAllofUs.org website even includes the strange bedfellows of the Chamber of Commerce and the ACLU.

And who’s for the referendum? Well, there’s no list of Nashville-based groups or community leaders on the English Only website so one would have to assume that their coalition consists of Councilman Crafton, Svengali Jon Crisp, ProEnglish (the Virginia-based group helping to fund Crafton’s referendum that was designated a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center because of it’s affiliation with John Tanton’s U.S. Inc.), and one not-so-friendly neighborhood truth-stretching talk radio host who, despite knowing that not all non-citizens who come to this country are sources of cheap labor (they are students, executives of international corporations, scientists, etc.) nor are they all seeking citizenship, wrote in the Tennessean last week:

It’s an undisputed fact that people who don’t have a working knowledge of English are either non-citizens or are illegal immigrants. How do I know? Because you are required by law to speak, write and understand English to become a U.S. citizen. Opposition to this measure, disguised as a pro-diversity coalition, is all about one thing: keeping a steady flow of cheap, illegal labor streaming into Nashville.

Oh, Teddy Roosevelt is with them too. Happy New Year 1919!

*No, she doesn’t.

  • Share/Bookmark

McCain Adviser: Are There Documented instances of voter fraud? “No.”

First, let’s establish the difference between election fraud and voter fraud. Election fraud is a systematic effort by those with power to steal an election through vote manipulation and voter suppression. Voter fraud is when a voter attempts to vote more than once or by impersonating someone else. The McCain campaign has been huckstering the false narrative of voter fraud. We’ll see to what end on Wednesday.

In the meantime, From Chisun Lee of ProPublica:

For weeks Republican leaders have warned that widely reported problems with fake voter registrations could result in a flood of phony votes in pivotal states.

But Ronald Michaelson, a veteran election administrator and member of the McCain-Palin Honest and Open Election Committee, said in an interview that he could not name a single instance in which this had occurred.

“Do we have a documented instance of voting fraud that resulted from a phony registration form? No, I can’t cite one, chapter and verse.”

Asked for specifics about the dangers of fake registration, Ben Porritt, a spokesman for the McCain campaign, provided links to 13 news clips and a 2003 Missouri state auditor’s report. Eleven of the cases did not involve registration fraud. Two recounted how felons appeared to have cast illegal votes under their own names. The lone example of a forged registration leading to an illegitimate vote comes from The Wall Street Journal’s John Fund, who in April 2006 wrote that a community organizer had improperly registered a noncitizen, and then “someone eventually voted in [the noncitizen’s] name.”

And this from Keith Olbermann (Who keeps showing up in my dreams. Last night he was waiting in the cafeteria line with FOL* Delworthio and family and he wanted to hang out. That was nice.)

And finally, Nashville has its own distortionist willing to spread the “voter fraud” myth. In last week’s Tennessean, Phil Valentine wrote that Tennessee may have it’s own version of ACORN:

Friday, a week ago, I got a tip on my radio show that vanloads of non-citizens were showing up at an early voting poll and voting. Lynn Greer, a Davidson County Election Commission member confirmed the report. “What I’ve heard is they’re bringing in a group of Spanish-speaking people, many of whom do not have a voter registration card and cannot speak English,” Greer told me.

Here’s my response (submitted to the Tennessean):

Like many, I waited all month for an “October Surprise,” – an event so monumental that it would cause enough chaos to affect the outcome of this year’s election. I never expected that the actual October Surprise would be something much more low key – the insidious, and coordinated attack on ACORN and the subsequent cries of “voter fraud” it has enabled.

After more than four years of activists trying to get election officials to take seriously the very real issue of election fraud, i.e. large scale voter roll purging, broken electronic voting machines, intimidation, long lines, and negative legislative influence (like Florida’s stringent “No Match, No Vote” law), the righteous indignation and moral high ground that comes with trying to protect our precious right to vote has been co-opted by Republican operatives who, in a matter of days, were able to get the false narrative of “voter fraud” on the lips of almost every broadcaster.

Senator McCain, Fox News, and other conservative ideologues, like Nashville’s own Phil Valentine. have reported incidences that “prove” multiple and fake voter registrations as well as the intent of some to cast non-legitimate ballots. These accusations come despite scant evidence (or convictions) of voter fraud, a federal law that requires ID from anyone voting for the first time (in Tennessee, showing your voter registration card is sufficient), and a report by the Brennan Center that states that voter fraud is “extremely rare.”

Last Sunday, Valentine wrote in his column that Nashville has its own “well-organized voter fraud ring” because of a tip he received about “vanloads of non-citizens” showing up at an early voting location. This incident did not happen and his reporting of it serves no purpose other than to stoke fear and division. And this election year, with emotions on both sides so heightened, his false accusations could prove to be incendiary.

This year’s October Surprise may not be dynamic enough to swing votes prior to the election, but with people like Phil Valentine spreading rumors and innuendo instead of fact, it certainly will cast doubt on the legitimacy of the winner afterwards. Which, unfortunately, seems to be the goal.

*Friend of Liberadio(!)

  • Share/Bookmark

Out of Context: Phil Valentine at the Southern Festival of Books

As I was reviewing the schedule for this year’s Southern Festival of Books, I was mildly surprised to see Phil Valentine as one of the featured authors. I knew he had a book out, but since book festivals are frequently teeming with people who read, qualifying them to be elitists, I wouldn’t have expected Mr. Valentine to bother to make the effort.

Because I think it’s important to know the enemy, I decided to attend Mr. Valentine’s session. I had thumbed through a review copy of his book, recently, and I was expecting to hear 20-30 minutes of the same tired old railing against liberalism for which Phil–following closely in the footsteps of Sean Hannity, who wrote the introduction to his book–is well-known and which is constant throughout the book. He sat down, took off his jacket while making an Al Gore global warming joke, and I figured I would settle in for a 20-minute episode of his show, on which misinformation about me has actually been spread before (back in 2002 when I challenged Beth Harwell for state house). He asked for a show of hands of who was conservative and then who was liberal, and he gave a revivalist pledge to “heal” the liberals. No surprises, yet.

But what followed was basically Phil Valentine as life coach rather than Phil Valentine as demagogue. Most of his discussion centered on his opposition to the bailout, and though he mentioned plenty of Democrats, he talked about the current crisis as a bipartisan crisis. And he wasn’t particularly gentle on McCain.

The rest was basically a discussion about personal responsibility. Valentine launched an attack on the liberal position on guns as part of this, but the rest was common sense rhetoric and not particularly inflammatory.

During the Q&A, I was almost impressed with the dialogue between the handful of other liberals in the room, some of the conservatives, and Valentine. Where I had been expecting to be made a spectacle of as one of the few who raised my hand as a “liberal,” much of the discussion was in good faith. Only at the very end did it go off the rails when a woman perpetuated the trend for conservative gatherings to include someone who is “terrified” of Obama, causing Valentine to tire swing briefly about Ayers. But the session as a whole was not a liberal- or Obama-bashing joyride or an excerpt from Reagan’s Famous Quotations. Instead it was stories about Phil’s dad, a former Democratic congressman in North Carolina, an anecdote about his family’s security being threatened in his home that caused him to decide to buy a gun, and other accessible extemporaneous moments.

By the end of the session, I had even learned that Phil makes his own biodiesel and I asked him more about the process.

Over the past few years, I have enjoyed or been pleasantly surprised by my encounters with several conservatives appearing out of context (Lou Dobbs, Newt Gingrich, Bill Haslam, Mark Norris, and now Phil Valentine to name a few) to the point that it’s disappointing to witness the pettiness and pandering that are so instrumental to our politics. Today’s session wasn’t a particularly inspiring discussion (and I was a little surprised that it was so lightly attended), but it was a surprising departure both from the book and the radio show.

We voters need to demand more of our candidates so that we change the context entirely to allow for more sincere discussions like the kind I continue to witness instead of the parade of frequently disingenuous attacks we witness during most competitive elections.

For the record, I love the Southern Festival of Books. I attended several other sessions.

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

Phil Valentine’s Lying Problem

My next post was going to be about Phil Valentine’s assertion in the Tennessean that “There is absolutely no evidence that carbon dioxide causes any kind of climate change.” Thanks, Bruce Barry, for saving me some key strokes:

And the nominees for most witless and uninformed assertion about the environment and climate change in a Sunday Tennessean op-ed this week are…

Bob Corker for his performance in “Return Cap-and-Trade Proceeds to People,” featuring this nugget: “No one can quantify how much of global warming is caused by natural cycles vs. man-made greenhouse emissions.”

Phil Valentine for his performance in “Earth Day Extremists were Wrong in the ’70s, and Still Are” featuring this gem: “There is absolutely no evidence that carbon dioxide causes any kind of climate change.”

Bonus! They both win! (And the Tennessean gets an honorable mention for “for outstanding editorial oversight in the pursuit of scientific integrity.”) Read the truth about these assertions here and here.

Mmmmmmmmmmmmm…I love the smell of intellectual dishonesty between 4 and 8 pm in the afternoon…

What amazes me about these talk show ideologues like Gill and Valentine is that they continue to cling hopelessly to their tired-old schtick when public opinion on everything from the war to global climate change is clearly evolving. I guess that’s what happens when you base your livelihood on narrowly-focused ideology rather than truth, civil dialogue, and the desire for smart public policy that works for everyone.

UPDATE: Liz Garrigan wants us to be fair to Corker.

  • Share/Bookmark

Liberadio(!) Podcast: One Extra Large Flyswatter, Please

Summary: It’s a cold day in hell on Liberadio(!) when we read a certain right-wing talk radio hosts’ Sunday column and our heads don’t explode. Plus, the integrity of our elections are still suspect, Rep. Rob Briley’s balancing act, Fred Thompson as Dick Gephardt, and isn’t “lozenge” a fun word to say?

Listen to: We Need a Very Large Flyswatter (:24:58 40MB)

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!

Visit our friends!

A few highly recommended friends...