As I was reviewing the schedule for this year’s Southern Festival of Books, I was mildly surprised to see Phil Valentine as one of the featured authors. I knew he had a book out, but since book festivals are frequently teeming with people who read, qualifying them to be elitists, I wouldn’t have expected Mr. Valentine to bother to make the effort.
Because I think it’s important to know the enemy, I decided to attend Mr. Valentine’s session. I had thumbed through a review copy of his book, recently, and I was expecting to hear 20-30 minutes of the same tired old railing against liberalism for which Phil–following closely in the footsteps of Sean Hannity, who wrote the introduction to his book–is well-known and which is constant throughout the book. He sat down, took off his jacket while making an Al Gore global warming joke, and I figured I would settle in for a 20-minute episode of his show, on which misinformation about me has actually been spread before (back in 2002 when I challenged Beth Harwell for state house). He asked for a show of hands of who was conservative and then who was liberal, and he gave a revivalist pledge to “heal” the liberals. No surprises, yet.
But what followed was basically Phil Valentine as life coach rather than Phil Valentine as demagogue. Most of his discussion centered on his opposition to the bailout, and though he mentioned plenty of Democrats, he talked about the current crisis as a bipartisan crisis. And he wasn’t particularly gentle on McCain.
The rest was basically a discussion about personal responsibility. Valentine launched an attack on the liberal position on guns as part of this, but the rest was common sense rhetoric and not particularly inflammatory.
During the Q&A, I was almost impressed with the dialogue between the handful of other liberals in the room, some of the conservatives, and Valentine. Where I had been expecting to be made a spectacle of as one of the few who raised my hand as a “liberal,” much of the discussion was in good faith. Only at the very end did it go off the rails when a woman perpetuated the trend for conservative gatherings to include someone who is “terrified” of Obama, causing Valentine to tire swing briefly about Ayers. But the session as a whole was not a liberal- or Obama-bashing joyride or an excerpt from Reagan’s Famous Quotations. Instead it was stories about Phil’s dad, a former Democratic congressman in North Carolina, an anecdote about his family’s security being threatened in his home that caused him to decide to buy a gun, and other accessible extemporaneous moments.
By the end of the session, I had even learned that Phil makes his own biodiesel and I asked him more about the process.
Over the past few years, I have enjoyed or been pleasantly surprised by my encounters with several conservatives appearing out of context (Lou Dobbs, Newt Gingrich, Bill Haslam, Mark Norris, and now Phil Valentine to name a few) to the point that it’s disappointing to witness the pettiness and pandering that are so instrumental to our politics. Today’s session wasn’t a particularly inspiring discussion (and I was a little surprised that it was so lightly attended), but it was a surprising departure both from the book and the radio show.
We voters need to demand more of our candidates so that we change the context entirely to allow for more sincere discussions like the kind I continue to witness instead of the parade of frequently disingenuous attacks we witness during most competitive elections.
For the record, I love the Southern Festival of Books. I attended several other sessions.
Recent Comments