Blue Collar Muse, well, muses about the latest email controversy coming out of the Tennessee General Assembly:

Will Lefty bloggers condemn this Democrat and call for his firing? Will the Media cover this on the news like they did the story of the GOP staffer? Will the Left police their own? Will this be written up and front paged at Daily Kos, Wonkette, and Think Progress? And what will the TNDP do? Will Chip Forrester lead the way and not merely call for the firing of this staffer but fire first and comment later?

Not necessary to muse any longer. In what has been described by House Democratic Caucus Chairman Mike Turner as a decision by Speaker Kent Williams, Blake P. Graves has been fired.

Between this latest kerfuffle and the disaster in Senator Dian Black’s office, it seems more than ever that we need to push to change the tone on Capitol Hill.

Perhaps the much-needed end-of-session seminar will cover not only the mechanics of policy (is that one warning or two?) but also empathy training. I’m envisioning a lot of “Walk a mile in a man’s shoes” type of stuff.

Update from Nashville21.com: “The “democrat” [pdf] in question appears to be an intern, Blake Graves, who was recently honored by a house resolution citing him as being the “best dressed intern” and recognizing his numerous accomplishments, including “dedicat[ing] his singular skills to several student and civic organizations, including the Student Activities Council, the College Republicans, and volunteering for Hands on Memphis and Volunteer Memphis”.”

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

As the House Turns

TN House Ethics Committee streaming live right now (10 am Central). The members are moseying – Chairman Jones, Turner, Mumpower, Odom, Harwell, et. al..

Will What will happen to Speaker Kent Williams? Find out now on As the House Turns! Dun-dun-duhn!

UPDATE: TN House Ethics Committee just recessed at the behest of Rep. Gary “Swingset” Odom to try and decide if the complaint against Williams is in their jurisdiction. (Swingset. He likes recesses. Get it?) Reconvene at 1:00 PM.

UPDATE II: More deets from Kleinheider.

UPDATE III: Those intrepid correspondents on the scene are reporting that Rep. Brian Kelsey, who brought the ethics complaint against Speaker Williams, is none too pleased with the lack of action on the part of the committee. From Woods at Pith:

“This is a complaint about sexual harassment and about lying to cover it up. Clearly this committee came in here with the idea that they are going to cover up this whole issue and not even investigate this. It’s really absurd.” …

“I don’t know where this committee is going right now, but if they came in here not ready to investigate it then that’s the wrong attitude to have when you’ve got serious allegations of sexual harassment and of lying about it to the public.” …

“I came here ready to have a hearing. We’ve got several members who were witnesses to this. To deny them the opportunity to comment on this is a travesty. The reason Representative Lynn is not here is that she had major feelings of stress this morning and she is in the hospital and unable to make it here. This is a serious charge. This is not a joking matter.”

If Rep. Lynn is indeed in the hospital because of the stress, we hope she gets the pharmaceuticals she needs. But since neither her staff nor other House Republicans seem able to confirm Kelsey’s report, he has some explaining to do. Is he so consumed by his obsession with his personal vendetta against Speaker Williams that with all the eyes of Tennessee’s best political reporters on him he’s attempting to create his own own reality to further his case? Disingenuous at best, delusional at worst.

Oh, and remember that mysterious person that attempted to interrupt this morning’s proceedings? The one we couldn’t see if we were watching the live streaming? If you thought it was an unhinged spectator who doesn’t understand Robert’s Rules of Order and wasn’t mature enough to contain his or her emotions, well, you were spot on! From Punk Rock in the Whitehouse:

When that committee convened this morning, Chairman Rep. Ulysses Jones (D-Memphis) asked the legal counsel whether the committee had jurisdiction over the case. Staff attorney Doug Hines said that he did not believe it did and that the matter is the domain of the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and Tennessee Human Rights Commission.

The statement caused Kelsey to jump out of his seat and say that he had an avenue in which the matter could be heard, to which Jones quickly banged his gavel and said Kelsey was out of order and had not been recognized.

UPDATE IV: During their short 1:00 session, Rep. Beth Harwell (R) made a motion for the ethics committee to NOT go ahead with hearing Kelsey’s complaint. The motion carried unanimously.

  • Share/Bookmark

Let’s face it, Tennessee Republicans, you got the political shaft. You had the 106th session of the General Assembly in your proverbial back pocket and then *poof* all your plans went up in a puff of back room shenanigans smoke.

Now you’re playing the victim – lamenting on how you’ve been betrayed by a RINO. And we’re not surprised because it’s what you guys do. I call it Trickle Down Victimization and conservatives in power do it better than anyone or anything else (especially governing). From President George Bush to the whatever conservative local talk radio host you listen to, you’re all about blaming others and presenting every issue in Us vs. Them terms. In other words, yours is the “Party of personal responsibility,” my patootie.

So no one should be surprised that after her Party got the political shellacking of her career, the messages sent by TN GOP Chair person Robin Smith, victim, who needs to be in total control and does not like to lose, went from the magnanimous post-election

“I think the Republican Party now is at a point in its life in maturity where we’re going to have to have regional messages…The party should not compromise its core ‘DNA’ of small government and lower taxes…but ought to allow for some deviation where politically necessary. We can’t just hang our hat on one social message”

to this week’s hostile

“Action will begin immediately to address the actions of Rep. Kent Williams…His commitment today was not to Republican Principles, but to the blind and shameless pursuit of personal power. He cast his vote for a Pro-Tax, Pro-Gay, Pro-Abortion, Anti-Gun Liberal Democrat to preside in leadership against all 49 of his Republican colleagues.”

We also shouldn’t be surprised by Rep. Kelsey’s call for Speaker Williams to resign while positioning the people of Carter County as victims. Or Rep. Campfield’s call for him to stay out of his angry and deceived face.

Because as the rest of the country moves on to a less divisive brand of politics and policy-making, you, my good Tennessee Republicans, still have that divide and conquer attitude of 1994. While we’ve gone to a place where governing, public policy, and compromise have become a priority, you’re still with the take no prisoners, win at all costs, my way or the highway mentality.

While some of your rank and file have come to terms with their anger (victim: Rep. Hawk’s sleeping patterns), even today, after you have had a few days to stew and simmer, you remain hostile and bitter. Maybe it will take a few more days until you are ready to capitalize on what is a rare opportunity and take Scott Dismuke’s advice to release the following statement:

While we are dissapointed [sic] with the results of today’s leadership elections, we are still committed to working to create opportunities for all Tennesseans at this critical time in our state.

We will work with Speaker Williams to make sure that all Tennesseans are proud of their elected officials, but more importantly, tackle the very tough issues facing our state.

At a time when Tennesseans are struggling to pay their electric bills, pay their mortgage, keep their jobs and put food on the table, we firmly believe that it is time to put people before politics.

There will be a time and place for the events of today to be dealt with, but right now, it is time to put politics to the side and start working together to ensure our government effectively works for all Tennesseans.

In other words, get over yourselves, check your egos at the Capitol door, and reconsider kicking Rep. Williams our of the your Republican club. Because if you don’t, you’ll force him further into the Democratic Party camp and the tenuous hold you have on the majority will slowly and painfully (for you) dissipate.

Be careful what you do in the name of revenge and while you’re still stinging from what has to be one of the more stunning political coups in Tennessee history.

Deep breaths, my friends. Deep breaths.

  • Share/Bookmark

Tennessee’s own Rashomon

There are always more than two sides to every story.

WSMV’s Cara Kumari is reporting that newly elected Speaker of the House Rep. Kent Williams (R, the Fightin’ 4th!) says he approached the Democrats about becoming speaker, “simply because he wanted to be speaker.”

The Scene’s Jeff Woods writes that House Democratic leader Gary Odom (D, the Fightin’ 55th!) traveled to Elizabethton to see Williams and “Out of the blue, Odom asked Williams how he’d like to be the speaker of the House.”

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

It’s always been impressive to watch Republicans fall in line – no matter what maneuverings might be going on behind the scenes, the unified front presented to the public is enviable. Democratic politicians, on the other hand, with their thinking for themselves and differences of opinion and not keeping a cork in it sometimes come across as disorganized and chaotic.

But today, with the election of Republican Speaker of House Kent Williams – nominated and seconded by Democrats – we see that the threats that often keep Republicans in line don’t work with everyone.

Since the elections we’ve watched as newly minted Tennessee Republican Senate and House Majority leaders have closed ranks and boasted of their unbreakable coalition. A coalition built on threats and hubris.

Some are warning liberals and progressives to be careful of celebrating the election of Speaker Williams. After all, he was nominated and put in power by the same “corrupt” Democrats who had no use for us and our progressive causes. Others say, well, he’s still a Republican, after all.

But what has happened in the Tennessee House today is historic and may mean a break with the politics of the past, similar to what’s happening on the national stage. What Tennesseans have in their new Speaker is a moderate Republican who, rather than fall in lock step, broke with his party and worked with Democrats to secure his leadership. And as such, he most likely won’t fall in lock step with House Democrats either.

Rep. Kent Williams may be the key to moving some progressive public policy forward while keeping the most divisive culture war legislation at bay.

  • Share/Bookmark

Rep. Lois DeBerry (D- The Fightin’ 91st!) voted in as Speaker Pro Tempore of the House.

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

Well Played So Far

Robin Smith, Chairperson of the Tennessee Republican Party, issued a statement regarding the election of Republican Kent Williams:

Kent Williams has betrayed his constituents and the people of Carter County in breaking his pledge – his signed oath – to vote for the nominee of the Republican caucus for Speaker of the House. He lied, in a quest for personal power, in league with Democrat Speaker Jimmy Naifeh and House Minority Leader Gary Odom, in their desire to retain power despite the results of the 2008 elections.

Here in the reality-based community, where the paper and digital record of the pledge lives, it’s clear that there was no betrayal and no broken pledge. The House Republicans just got bested. The full language of the pledge reads:

Republicans Committed to Voting for Republican House Officers

NASHVILLE – Together, as members of the House Republican Caucus, we are proud to announce our unified commitment to vote for a Republican for Speaker of the Tennessee House of Representatives.

We also commit to vote for a Republican Speaker Pro Tempore. This is yet another historic moment in a series of what has already been and what we are sure will continue to be historic events leading
to the Republican control of the Tennessee House.

We are all honored and humbled by the trust Tennessee voters placed in us both individually, as representatives of our own districts, and collectively as a majority. Tennessee voters asked for change
by electing Republicans to lead, and Tennessee voters are ready for common sense to make a comeback in government. We take the responsibilities that come with being the majority party very seriously
and are ready to meet the challenges ahead.

As a visual sign of our commitment, all 50 House Republicans have signed this document:

Rep. Kent Williams gets kicked out of the Republican Caucus in 3…2…1…or does he?

UPDATE: OK, the reality-based community must acknowledge that when Williams voted for Speaker Pro Tempore DeBerry, he broke his pledge.

  • Share/Bookmark

Rep. Williams Keeps His Promise

Rep. Kent Williams (R, The Fightin’ 4th! ) kept his promise to vote for a Republican for Speaker of the House. He voted for Republican Kent Williams. Guess the pledge Rep. Mumpower made all members of his party sign should have been more specific. Rep. Williams is now Speaker of the House for the State of Tennessee. The final tally was 50-49. Oooo, so close!

  • Share/Bookmark