Mayor Karl Dean will join Governor Phil Bredesen at the Howard School Building on Monday morning, Jan. 12, at 8:00 am to early vote against Councilman Eric Crafton’s “English-only” charter amendment and Amendment No. 2, which would make it absurdly easy to bring these kinds of referendums to a public vote (twice a year!). Then, the next day, Andrea Conte (Mrs. Governor Bredesen), Anne Davis (Mrs. Mayor Dean) and Martha Cooper (Mrs. Congressman Cooper, who let’s us call her “Mrs. Coop!”*) will do the same at 12:30 p.m.

Today, African-American leaders, community organizers, and public officials including Rep. Brenda Gilmore, Councillady Erica Gilmore, and Councilman at large Jerry Maynard, held a press conference in front of the Howard School to encourage votes of “Against/Against.” The coalition standing with them included representatives from the Nashville branch of the NAACP; the Urban EpiCenter; the Urban League of Middle Tennessee; the Interdenominational Ministers Fellowship (IMF); the Tennessee Immigrant & Refugee Rights Coalition (TIRRC); the Nashville Movement; the Tennessee Alliance for Progress (TAP); Jobs with Justice (JwJ); and the National Organization for Women (NOW).

The remarks focused on the social, economic, spiritual and moral impact of the referendum as well as the myth that most African-Americans were for the referendum. Although no statistics were cited, Councilman Maynard did explain that a lingering resentment over a lack of coalition building in response to school rezoning, the operation of Metro General Hospital, and juvenile crime statistics could be responsible for fueling pro-English Only sentiment in the African-American community. Maynard’s answer to such resentment is to cite the potential negative impact of the English Only referendum on the city and offer the tried and true adage of “two wrongs don’t make a right.”

The Mayor, the Governor, respected community leaders of all kinds. The coalition against the referendum is impressive. The list on the NashvilleForAllofUs.org website even includes the strange bedfellows of the Chamber of Commerce and the ACLU.

And who’s for the referendum? Well, there’s no list of Nashville-based groups or community leaders on the English Only website so one would have to assume that their coalition consists of Councilman Crafton, Svengali Jon Crisp, ProEnglish (the Virginia-based group helping to fund Crafton’s referendum that was designated a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center because of it’s affiliation with John Tanton’s U.S. Inc.), and one not-so-friendly neighborhood truth-stretching talk radio host who, despite knowing that not all non-citizens who come to this country are sources of cheap labor (they are students, executives of international corporations, scientists, etc.) nor are they all seeking citizenship, wrote in the Tennessean last week:

It’s an undisputed fact that people who don’t have a working knowledge of English are either non-citizens or are illegal immigrants. How do I know? Because you are required by law to speak, write and understand English to become a U.S. citizen. Opposition to this measure, disguised as a pro-diversity coalition, is all about one thing: keeping a steady flow of cheap, illegal labor streaming into Nashville.

Oh, Teddy Roosevelt is with them too. Happy New Year 1919!

*No, she doesn’t.

  • Share/Bookmark

So, Eric Crafton’s a good guy. A smart guy. He’s just a little too “alarmingly left-brained” to understand that learning a foreign language with the “full backing and resources of the American Navy…is so removed from the life of your average Nashville non-native speaker that it might as well take place on another planet.” He’s a no-nonsense, black or white, right or wrong, pull-yourself-up-by-your-bootstraps family man. According to those who know him best, his colleagues on the Metro Council, he’s not a bad guy.

Let’s say, for argument sake, that all of the above is true. If so, then Crafton is also a little too “alarmingly left-brained” and a little too driven by his ideals to see that he’s being manipulated by Jon Crisp, his “friend” and former head of the Davidson County GOP.

Because Crisp, in this week’s Nashville Scene cover story, let the singular purpose of the “English Only” Amendment slip:

Crafton certainly saw no gray in English Only when he and his friend and adviser Jon Crisp devised it a couple of years ago. Crisp says that English Only came to be during one of his and Crafton’s regular spitball sessions.

“Eric and I pick up on topics that we think are timely,” he says. “And you know as well as I do that any given day I can make an issue out of illegal immigration.”

Yes. We know. You’re, uh, doing it right now. You topic is “timely” because since 2004, when then-Senator Majority leader Bill Frist first introduced immigration as a problem, the unholy alliance of right-wing cable TV anouncers, talk radio hosts, and Fox News have increasingly inflamed nativist sentiment. Nashville’s version of the cookie cutter “English First” website may say that having English as the official language is “truly inclusive” and “essential to unifying our increasingly diverse population,” but Crisp’s transparent words say “purposefully exclusionary” and “essential to dividing in order to conquer.”

The well-being of the city and people of Nashville may be part of the Crafton/Crisp (aka Crispton) official talking points, but the truth is that they could really care less. My thanks to Crisp for finally admitting it.

  • Share/Bookmark

Right now, you probably have visions of sugar plums, peppermint mochas, or Cranberry Cosmos dancing around in your head. Yeah, it’s that time of year. But see if you can fit a little participatory democracy in there as well because come January 2, 2009, we’ll be hauling our butts back into the voting booth to vote against the Metro Charter Amendment that would force all Metro Government communications and publications to be in English only.

Today, a broad coalition of Nashville’s citizens, community leaders, and business owners launched NashvilleForAllofUs.org, the beginning of the movement to urge the residents of Davidson County to vote against the English-only Metro Charter amendment. At NashvilleForAllofUs.org you can find out more information about the coalition, sign up to volunteer and spread the word, and contribute to their work to defeat this referendum.

Liberadio(!) is part of the coalition, and on Monday we had a lengthy discussion with one of our regular listeners who thought the “English-Only” Charter Amendment was a good idea [Listen]. We, obviously, do not.

Here is what the amendment proposes:

English is the official language of the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County, Tennessee. Official actions which bind or commit the government shall be taken only in the English language, and all official government communications and publications shall be in English. No person shall have a right to government services in any other language. All meetings of the Metro Council, Boards, and Commissions of the Metropolitan Government shall be conducted in English. The Metro Council may make specific exceptions to protect public health and safety. Nothing in this measure shall be interpreted to conflict with federal or state law.

The amendment, which is clearly “English-only” and not “English-first,” is excessive, inefficient, and dangerous.

Excessive because Tennessee state law already codifies English as the “official and legal language” of our state. Inefficient because the translation of essential documents by Metro agencies makes the bureaucracy run more smoothly for all residents. Dangerous because the ability of Nashville government to communicate with all city residents, especially those who might have important information to share with government officials, is essential for public safety.

Nashville has always been known to business leaders, students, and the many visitors that our tourism industry relies on as an inclusive community. This amendment will discriminate against all foreign-born people who visit or come to live or study here, including refugees who have come to this country to escape discrimination. Ironic, ain’t it?

Some important facts:

  • On August 7 , 2008, the Metro Council voted 25-8 urging voters to oppose an English-only charter amendment. Mayor Dean himself addressed the council: “I wanted to take this time, this opportunity to make sure my voice, as mayor of this city, is heard on this issue, and to assure that everyone fully understands the consequences of passing a law that will tie our hands in the global economy, that will detract from our appeal as an international tourist destination, and that will damage our reputation as a welcoming and friendly city.”
  • According to the Nashville Chamber of Commerce, Japanese investment alone in Tennessee exceeded $9.4 billion in 2004, creating over 40,000 jobs.
  • Research indicates that 98% of Latinos think it is “essential” that their children learn English. In fact, 80% of foreign-born children from Mexico learn English “well” or “very well,” and 92 percent of second-generation Latinos are fully fluent in English. By the third generation, only 28% of Latinos are still proficient in Spanish. (Migration Policy Institute).
  • Immigrants are required to learn English before they become U.S. citizens (exceptions include older immigrants). While they are learning English and going through the long citizenship process, they must still interact with government agencies.
  • There are over 45,000 foreign-born individuals in Davidson County who are still working towards their citizenship.
  • According to the Davidson County Election Commission, January’s special election to decide the fate of this ballot initiative will cost Nashville taxpayers approximately $350,000 to $500,000. This during a time when Metro is being forced to take a good, hard, long look at our budget and make necessary cuts.

So in the midst of all that Holiday cheer you’ll be spreading with your giftees and your parties, think about what makes Nashville unique as a city in Tennessee and what we’ll lose if this amendment passes. And then take the time to tell your friends – in between cups of holiday cheer, of course – to get out and vote.

Vote against the “English-Only” referendum on January 22, 2009. Early voting begins on January 2, 2009. Last day to register to vote in this election is December 23, 2008. Call the Davidson County Election Commission for more information at 615-862-8800.

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

  • Share/Bookmark

Does Eric Crafton’s “Nashville English First Petition” website really mean to imply that Theodore Roosevelt’s 101 year old quotes on immigration include a direct reference to English being the official language of the Metropolitan Government of Nashville and Davidson County, or am I missing something?

Nashvilleenglishfirst.com Website

  • Share/Bookmark

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!

Visit our friends!

A few highly recommended friends...