It’s always been impressive to watch Republicans fall in line – no matter what maneuverings might be going on behind the scenes, the unified front presented to the public is enviable. Democratic politicians, on the other hand, with their thinking for themselves and differences of opinion and not keeping a cork in it sometimes come across as disorganized and chaotic.

But today, with the election of Republican Speaker of House Kent Williams – nominated and seconded by Democrats – we see that the threats that often keep Republicans in line don’t work with everyone.

Since the elections we’ve watched as newly minted Tennessee Republican Senate and House Majority leaders have closed ranks and boasted of their unbreakable coalition. A coalition built on threats and hubris.

Some are warning liberals and progressives to be careful of celebrating the election of Speaker Williams. After all, he was nominated and put in power by the same “corrupt” Democrats who had no use for us and our progressive causes. Others say, well, he’s still a Republican, after all.

But what has happened in the Tennessee House today is historic and may mean a break with the politics of the past, similar to what’s happening on the national stage. What Tennesseans have in their new Speaker is a moderate Republican who, rather than fall in lock step, broke with his party and worked with Democrats to secure his leadership. And as such, he most likely won’t fall in lock step with House Democrats either.

Rep. Kent Williams may be the key to moving some progressive public policy forward while keeping the most divisive culture war legislation at bay.

  • Share/Bookmark

Rep. Lois DeBerry (D- The Fightin’ 91st!) voted in as Speaker Pro Tempore of the House.

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

Well Played So Far

Robin Smith, Chairperson of the Tennessee Republican Party, issued a statement regarding the election of Republican Kent Williams:

Kent Williams has betrayed his constituents and the people of Carter County in breaking his pledge – his signed oath – to vote for the nominee of the Republican caucus for Speaker of the House. He lied, in a quest for personal power, in league with Democrat Speaker Jimmy Naifeh and House Minority Leader Gary Odom, in their desire to retain power despite the results of the 2008 elections.

Here in the reality-based community, where the paper and digital record of the pledge lives, it’s clear that there was no betrayal and no broken pledge. The House Republicans just got bested. The full language of the pledge reads:

Republicans Committed to Voting for Republican House Officers

NASHVILLE – Together, as members of the House Republican Caucus, we are proud to announce our unified commitment to vote for a Republican for Speaker of the Tennessee House of Representatives.

We also commit to vote for a Republican Speaker Pro Tempore. This is yet another historic moment in a series of what has already been and what we are sure will continue to be historic events leading
to the Republican control of the Tennessee House.

We are all honored and humbled by the trust Tennessee voters placed in us both individually, as representatives of our own districts, and collectively as a majority. Tennessee voters asked for change
by electing Republicans to lead, and Tennessee voters are ready for common sense to make a comeback in government. We take the responsibilities that come with being the majority party very seriously
and are ready to meet the challenges ahead.

As a visual sign of our commitment, all 50 House Republicans have signed this document:

Rep. Kent Williams gets kicked out of the Republican Caucus in 3…2…1…or does he?

UPDATE: OK, the reality-based community must acknowledge that when Williams voted for Speaker Pro Tempore DeBerry, he broke his pledge.

  • Share/Bookmark

Rep. Williams Keeps His Promise

Rep. Kent Williams (R, The Fightin’ 4th! ) kept his promise to vote for a Republican for Speaker of the House. He voted for Republican Kent Williams. Guess the pledge Rep. Mumpower made all members of his party sign should have been more specific. Rep. Williams is now Speaker of the House for the State of Tennessee. The final tally was 50-49. Oooo, so close!

  • Share/Bookmark

It’s been a very telling day.

Nathan Moore, an English Only opponent and a “keen conservative legal mind”, digs up some pertinent info from Green Bay, Wisconsin, one of the bigger cities to have passed an English Only ordinance.

Councilman Eric Crafton, the English Only referendum sponsor, attempts to back out of a scheduled debate obligation because “If Karl Dean doesn’t have enough time to come,” he said. “I don’t see why I should.”

Sean Braisted, English Only opponent, calls Crafton on some of his New York Times-worthy anecdotal evidence (and makes an appropriate analogy).

Lady with a car, who is either for Crafton’s referendum or just really loves signage, almost runs over FOL* and Loews Vanderbilt Plaza Hotel Managing Director Tom Negri, while stealing an “Against/Against” lawn sign.

A day like this makes it even more apparent that the clearer heads in this English Only battle are those who are against the referendum.

*Friend of Liberadio(!)

  • Share/Bookmark

Summary: Guests include Tom Negri, Managing Director of the Loews Vanderbilt Plaza Hotel, and Dr. David Rosnick, economist for the Center for Economic and Policy Research.

Part 1 – Straight Only, White Only, Christian Only, Republican Only, Women Only – Oh when oh when will it end? When you get out and vote against/against! [6 MB 03:48 download MP3]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Part 2 – Interview with Tom Negri. Tom is the Managing Director of Loews Vanderbilt Plaza Hotel, on the board of the Chamber of Commerce, and a founding member of Nashville’s Coalition For Education About Immigration. He knows real immigration reform and what’s good for business and Councilman Eric Crafton’s English Only referendum is neither. [40.2 MB 25:04 download MP3]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Part 3 – Vote Vote Like a Baby Stoat – Our listeners weigh in on English Only and help us, with apologies to CuteOverload.com, urge everyone to get out and vote vote like a baby stoat. And then tell your friends to do the same. [45.7 MB 28:33 download MP3]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Part 4 – Interview with Dr. David Rosnick – In this interview, bearded economist Dr. Rosnick of the Center for Economic and Policy Research does just what his organization promises, he presents the economic crisis, President-Elect Obama’s stimulus package, and the bailout in a progressive, accurate and understandable manner. And it’s always nice to hear an economist giggle. [25MB 15.34 download MP3]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

Part 5 – The Nashville Last Crowd – We’re told that we’re anti-English if we’re against English Only, which is both not true and kinda funny because we’re all, you know, speaking English. What’s not funny is Steve Gill and his Nashville Last crowd who will vote for the English Only referendum despite the documented negative impact it will have on the city. Plus, the Tennessee General Assembly reconvenes with some Republican-led turmoil (shades of things to come?), President Bush personally authorized torture, and don’t just listen to what President-elect Obama says, watch what he does. [46.5MB 29:00 download MP3]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

  • Share/Bookmark

Anti-Anti-English

On this morning’s This Week with Bob Mueller, Steve Gill labeled those who are against Councilman Eric Crafton’s English Only referendum the “Anti-English crowd.” I know he likes his catch phrases – leaving out any semblance of a nuanced argument makes it easy for him to inflame the masses with feelings of false persecution – but considering all involved in the discussion were, you know, speaking English, it was terribly absurd.

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

The Cheney Who Ate the Canary

Think Progress hones in on the part of Wolf Blitzer’s interview with Dick Cheney where he shrugs off the importance of capturing Osama Bin Laden.

After the 9/11 attacks, President Bush famously declared that he would capture Osama bin Laden “dead or alive.” However, less than a year later — in March 2002 — Bush said that he was “not that concerned” about the al Qaeda leader. Today on CNN’s Late Edition, host Wolf Blitzer asked Vice President Cheney, “How frustrating is this to you personally, knowing he’s [bin Laden] still at large?” Cheney hesitated, then simply replied that he would “obviously…like to solve that problem.” He added that it’s more “important” to “keep…this country safe,” indicating that bin Laden is inconsequential.

But should we be glossing over the first part of Cheney’s answer to the question of why hasn’t the administration captured Bin Laden yet? Does “well, we have a few days left, Wolf” mean that the “history will prove us right” spin of the Bush Legacy Project is foreshadowing the upstaging of the Obama inauguration with an Osama capture? Is that a Chesire Cheney we see in this interview?

If not, Cheney’s nonchalance and off the cuff retort does nothing but denigrate the memory of those lost on 9/11 and prove to the families affected by the tragedy just how much he really cares.

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

We learned three things from Nathan Moore today. One, Nashville does not employ many physically-present interpreters (they are only found in the Health Department and the courts) but rather we use AT&T’s translation service; Two, we spend $110,00.00 per year for this service; And, three, Eric Crafton’s English Only Amendment will save the city of Nashville approximately $495.00 per year.

Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act (along with Executive Order 13166) determines that any local government department receiving federal funds must provide its services in multiple languages, because the law says we cannot disciminate against individuals based on national origin.

Here is the useage breakdown of Metro’s interpretation services (these numbers were provided to me by the mayor’s office)

Health 41.71%
Police / Sheriff 33.13%
Juvenile / Courts 7.95%
Metro Water 6.62%
General Hospital/Bordeaux 9.43%
Nashville Career Advis. 0.71%

All of the above departments receive Title VI funds. The total is 99.55%. It appears I was more than generous with my previous estimate of 97%. This means that the passage of English Only could only affect 0.045% of the money spent, which means that Metro would save $495 per year. Or, we could just give back $250 million in federal funds each year.

The election is going to cost somewhere between $300,000 and $500,000 to conduct. This means it will take somwhere between 606 years and 1010 years to realize the nominal savings on this election.

Ah, I love the smell of number crunching in the morning.

  • Share/Bookmark
Tagged with:
 

Mayor Karl Dean will join Governor Phil Bredesen at the Howard School Building on Monday morning, Jan. 12, at 8:00 am to early vote against Councilman Eric Crafton’s “English-only” charter amendment and Amendment No. 2, which would make it absurdly easy to bring these kinds of referendums to a public vote (twice a year!). Then, the next day, Andrea Conte (Mrs. Governor Bredesen), Anne Davis (Mrs. Mayor Dean) and Martha Cooper (Mrs. Congressman Cooper, who let’s us call her “Mrs. Coop!”*) will do the same at 12:30 p.m.

Today, African-American leaders, community organizers, and public officials including Rep. Brenda Gilmore, Councillady Erica Gilmore, and Councilman at large Jerry Maynard, held a press conference in front of the Howard School to encourage votes of “Against/Against.” The coalition standing with them included representatives from the Nashville branch of the NAACP; the Urban EpiCenter; the Urban League of Middle Tennessee; the Interdenominational Ministers Fellowship (IMF); the Tennessee Immigrant & Refugee Rights Coalition (TIRRC); the Nashville Movement; the Tennessee Alliance for Progress (TAP); Jobs with Justice (JwJ); and the National Organization for Women (NOW).

The remarks focused on the social, economic, spiritual and moral impact of the referendum as well as the myth that most African-Americans were for the referendum. Although no statistics were cited, Councilman Maynard did explain that a lingering resentment over a lack of coalition building in response to school rezoning, the operation of Metro General Hospital, and juvenile crime statistics could be responsible for fueling pro-English Only sentiment in the African-American community. Maynard’s answer to such resentment is to cite the potential negative impact of the English Only referendum on the city and offer the tried and true adage of “two wrongs don’t make a right.”

The Mayor, the Governor, respected community leaders of all kinds. The coalition against the referendum is impressive. The list on the NashvilleForAllofUs.org website even includes the strange bedfellows of the Chamber of Commerce and the ACLU.

And who’s for the referendum? Well, there’s no list of Nashville-based groups or community leaders on the English Only website so one would have to assume that their coalition consists of Councilman Crafton, Svengali Jon Crisp, ProEnglish (the Virginia-based group helping to fund Crafton’s referendum that was designated a hate group by the Southern Poverty Law Center because of it’s affiliation with John Tanton’s U.S. Inc.), and one not-so-friendly neighborhood truth-stretching talk radio host who, despite knowing that not all non-citizens who come to this country are sources of cheap labor (they are students, executives of international corporations, scientists, etc.) nor are they all seeking citizenship, wrote in the Tennessean last week:

It’s an undisputed fact that people who don’t have a working knowledge of English are either non-citizens or are illegal immigrants. How do I know? Because you are required by law to speak, write and understand English to become a U.S. citizen. Opposition to this measure, disguised as a pro-diversity coalition, is all about one thing: keeping a steady flow of cheap, illegal labor streaming into Nashville.

Oh, Teddy Roosevelt is with them too. Happy New Year 1919!

*No, she doesn’t.

  • Share/Bookmark

Looking for something?

Use the form below to search the site:

Still not finding what you're looking for? Drop a comment on a post or contact us so we can take care of it!

Visit our friends!

A few highly recommended friends...